Discussion:
What It Was Like Being Forced to Leave Palestine 60 Years Ago
(too old to reply)
i***@stable.bin
2009-01-13 16:31:38 UTC
Permalink
What It Was Like Being Forced to Leave Palestine 60 Years Ago

By Suzanne Manneh, New America Media. Posted January 13, 2009.

Palestinian expats tell their stories from decades ago when they were
forced to flee their homeland.

Editor's Note: The current conflict between Hamas forces and Israel
has rekindled memories among many Palestinian expats of a time more
than six decades ago when they were forced to flee their homeland as
violence erupted there. A 78-year-old Palestinian expat, who wants to
remain anonymous, shares some of those memories with New America Media
reporter Suzanne Manneh.

DALY CITY, Calif. -- It's been 61 years since I've seen my homeland of
Palestine. I'm one of many Palestinian elders living in exile. And
sadly, one of many who may not live to see home again.

I left Jaffa, Palestine, now part of Israel, when I was 17. It was a
violent time in Palestine, leading up to the Nakba, Arabic for
catastrophe, the expulsion of Palestinians from Palestine, and the
creation of Israel.

My family and I fled on April 27, 1948. My cousin, who lived a block
away from me, was severely injured from a missile attack on our
neighborhood, but survived. The next day, Jewish defense forces said
we had to leave or die, so we packed whatever we could, as fast as we
could, and left for Jordan, hoping for a more peaceful, stable life.
But an unstable Jordanian economy in the 1970's ended that dream and
started another, in the United States.

When I came to the United States, I hid the fact that I was
Palestinian, or even Arab. I said I was Greek. I was worried Americans
would call me a terrorist and reject me. I surrendered my homeland and
my identity as well. Some found out I was Palestinian and insulted me.

In the last two weeks, I've been glued to my television set, watching
from my home here in California the fighting between Hamas and Israel
in Gaza. And as I watch, I cry. Watching this is the closest I think I
can get to home.

My last memories of home are like this. Chaos. Death. Blood. Tears.
Fear. Anger. Screaming. And above all sadness, so much sadness. One
minute you're enjoying a meal with your family and boom! you're
uprooted.

One afternoon, at the end of January 1948, I was riding my bicycle
home from my father's taxicab business. I was in downtown Jaffa and
saw one of my uncles riding his bike. "Hurry on home!" he yelled, "I
hear this area is next to get bombed!"

I didn't believe him, but I didn’t want to take any chances. I rode
toward my house and he toward his. Seconds later, I heard a huge
explosion. I saw buildings go up in smoke and fires behind me.
Hundreds of people were running in the streets, screaming. I was
shaking uncontrollably when I got home. I learned that my uncle had
died in the explosion.

The violence escalated in the following days. My Jewish friends were
shocked. They couldn't believe what was happening. There had been
riots before, a little violence, but never like this.

Each day there were more attacks. Palestinians felt they had to
retaliate, so it became violence against violence.

The Jewish defense forces began forcing people to leave their homes.
If they didn't, they would kill everyone, they said. I remember
Palestinian girls getting raped. I saw three sisters from my
neighborhood jump into a well because the defense forces tried to rape
them.

Many families who didn't have cars in which to escape scrambled to
find a family that did. They squished into them, 12 to15 people to a
car.

Others managed to take boats north into Lebanon. Some fled by foot.
Many of them died of dehydration and exhaustion while escaping. We
were lucky. We had a cab from my father's taxicab company at home and
we drove off in it, leaving everything else behind.

The other day, I saw a close-up of a little girl's face on my TV
screen. She was four, maybe five, years old. Her eyes were swollen
from crying. She was screaming, "Mommy! Daddy! Mommy! Where are you? I
need you!" Her parents had been killed in missile attacks.

When I saw her eyes, I remembered a little girl from 1948 in my
neighborhood. She too had eyes swollen from crying. She found her
parents shot dead in front of her home. They hadn't cooperated when
they were told to leave. The little girl was still asleep inside the
house.

In that violence, over 750,000 Palestinians were forced out. But today
I see cruelty that cannot compare to 1948. This is worse than a
slaughterhouse. I see fields of human bodies with arms and legs
missing. I see dead bodies lying on top of each other in pools of
blood, injured people, homes turned to rubble.

I see children in the streets all alone. I see people crying. They
have been without food, water, medicine and electricity for weeks.

In 1948, I thought the Palestinian issue was just a Palestinian issue,
but this current conflict has become a global humanitarian crisis.
International human rights are being violated. Palestinians deserve a
home, deserve peace, just like everyone else.

Growing up in Palestine, I had many Jewish, Muslim and Christian
friends. You could sense the harmony between us.

I remember many of them visiting me in Jaffa. I, in turn, would visit
them in Gaza, an hour's drive away. I still remember the smell of
fresh citrus and wild flowers in the air.

I haven't seen or heard from them since I came to the United States.
I'm not sure if they're okay, or even if they’re still alive. I have
no way of finding out. When I fled Palestine, I was lucky to have my
parents, brothers, sisters and a few other immediate relatives to stay
with. It was impossible to keep track of everyone else you knew when
you were ripped apart from everything and everyone.

After the state of Israel was created, the Israeli government made it
difficult for Palestinians to return to their homeland. If I had to go
back, I would first need to complete forms and be investigated before
I am given permission. Imagine needing permission to go home. It's
like someone ripping my heart out, stepping on it and feeding it to
the lions. If there had been peace in Palestine, I would have
preferred to be there now, even if it meant living like a peasant.

I cried and prayed for peace in 1948, and every time a fresh outbreak
of violence erupted. For too long I have been hearing the terms,
"cease fire" and "peace talks."

But historically, that part of the world has been an unending cycle of
violence and ceasefire. I don't want to see this cycle continue. There
must be peace, real peace, and equality.

The only thing I can do now as a 78-year-old man is to pray. Pray for
my people. Pray for everyone. Pray for peace.
Scratch
2009-01-13 17:28:37 UTC
Permalink
Post by i***@stable.bin
What It Was Like Being Forced to Leave Palestine 60 Years Ago
By Suzanne Manneh, New America Media. Posted January 13, 2009.
Palestinian expats tell their stories from decades ago when they were
forced to flee their homeland.
Editor's Note: The current conflict between Hamas forces and Israel
has rekindled memories among many Palestinian expats of a time more
than six decades ago when they were forced to flee their homeland as
violence erupted there. A 78-year-old Palestinian expat, who wants to
remain anonymous, shares some of those memories with New America Media
reporter Suzanne Manneh.
DALY CITY, Calif. -- It's been 61 years since I've seen my homeland of
Palestine. I'm one of many Palestinian elders living in exile. And
sadly, one of many who may not live to see home again.
I left Jaffa, Palestine, now part of Israel, when I was 17. It was a
violent time in Palestine, leading up to the Nakba, Arabic for
catastrophe, the expulsion of Palestinians from Palestine, and the
creation of Israel.
My family and I fled on April 27, 1948. My cousin, who lived a block
away from me, was severely injured from a missile attack on our
neighborhood, but survived. The next day, Jewish defense forces said
we had to leave or die, so we packed whatever we could, as fast as we
could, and left for Jordan, hoping for a more peaceful, stable life.
But an unstable Jordanian economy in the 1970's ended that dream and
started another, in the United States.
When I came to the United States, I hid the fact that I was
Palestinian, or even Arab. I said I was Greek. I was worried Americans
would call me a terrorist and reject me. I surrendered my homeland and
my identity as well. Some found out I was Palestinian and insulted me.
In the last two weeks, I've been glued to my television set, watching
from my home here in California the fighting between Hamas and Israel
in Gaza. And as I watch, I cry. Watching this is the closest I think I
can get to home.
My last memories of home are like this. Chaos. Death. Blood. Tears.
Fear. Anger. Screaming. And above all sadness, so much sadness. One
minute you're enjoying a meal with your family and boom! you're
uprooted.
One afternoon, at the end of January 1948, I was riding my bicycle
home from my father's taxicab business. I was in downtown Jaffa and
saw one of my uncles riding his bike. "Hurry on home!" he yelled, "I
hear this area is next to get bombed!"
I didn't believe him, but I didn't want to take any chances. I rode
toward my house and he toward his. Seconds later, I heard a huge
explosion. I saw buildings go up in smoke and fires behind me.
Hundreds of people were running in the streets, screaming. I was
shaking uncontrollably when I got home. I learned that my uncle had
died in the explosion.
The violence escalated in the following days. My Jewish friends were
shocked. They couldn't believe what was happening. There had been
riots before, a little violence, but never like this.
Each day there were more attacks. Palestinians felt they had to
retaliate, so it became violence against violence.
The Jewish defense forces began forcing people to leave their homes.
If they didn't, they would kill everyone, they said. I remember
Palestinian girls getting raped. I saw three sisters from my
neighborhood jump into a well because the defense forces tried to rape
them.
Many families who didn't have cars in which to escape scrambled to
find a family that did. They squished into them, 12 to15 people to a
car.
Others managed to take boats north into Lebanon. Some fled by foot.
Many of them died of dehydration and exhaustion while escaping. We
were lucky. We had a cab from my father's taxicab company at home and
we drove off in it, leaving everything else behind.
The other day, I saw a close-up of a little girl's face on my TV
screen. She was four, maybe five, years old. Her eyes were swollen
from crying. She was screaming, "Mommy! Daddy! Mommy! Where are you? I
need you!" Her parents had been killed in missile attacks.
When I saw her eyes, I remembered a little girl from 1948 in my
neighborhood. She too had eyes swollen from crying. She found her
parents shot dead in front of her home. They hadn't cooperated when
they were told to leave. The little girl was still asleep inside the
house.
In that violence, over 750,000 Palestinians were forced out. But today
I see cruelty that cannot compare to 1948. This is worse than a
slaughterhouse. I see fields of human bodies with arms and legs
missing. I see dead bodies lying on top of each other in pools of
blood, injured people, homes turned to rubble.
I see children in the streets all alone. I see people crying. They
have been without food, water, medicine and electricity for weeks.
In 1948, I thought the Palestinian issue was just a Palestinian issue,
but this current conflict has become a global humanitarian crisis.
International human rights are being violated. Palestinians deserve a
home, deserve peace, just like everyone else.
Growing up in Palestine, I had many Jewish, Muslim and Christian
friends. You could sense the harmony between us.
I remember many of them visiting me in Jaffa. I, in turn, would visit
them in Gaza, an hour's drive away. I still remember the smell of
fresh citrus and wild flowers in the air.
I haven't seen or heard from them since I came to the United States.
I'm not sure if they're okay, or even if they're still alive. I have
no way of finding out. When I fled Palestine, I was lucky to have my
parents, brothers, sisters and a few other immediate relatives to stay
with. It was impossible to keep track of everyone else you knew when
you were ripped apart from everything and everyone.
After the state of Israel was created, the Israeli government made it
difficult for Palestinians to return to their homeland. If I had to go
back, I would first need to complete forms and be investigated before
I am given permission. Imagine needing permission to go home. It's
like someone ripping my heart out, stepping on it and feeding it to
the lions. If there had been peace in Palestine, I would have
preferred to be there now, even if it meant living like a peasant.
I cried and prayed for peace in 1948, and every time a fresh outbreak
of violence erupted. For too long I have been hearing the terms,
"cease fire" and "peace talks."
But historically, that part of the world has been an unending cycle of
violence and ceasefire. I don't want to see this cycle continue. There
must be peace, real peace, and equality.
The only thing I can do now as a 78-year-old man is to pray. Pray for
my people. Pray for everyone. Pray for peace.
Yea, sad. Also sad that the Israelis' and their children have been
constantly under attack for longer than most people care to remember. But
when you have palis' raising their children to murder Israelis' and think
of their women as nothing more than breeders to make more terrorist that
care little for life. That is even tougher and it is tough for someone
like me to feel sorry for them. It was NOT the Israelis' that made HAMAS
feel at home in their country either. Was that from Chicken Soup for the
Pali Soul?
--
Government is not the solution to our problem; government 'is' the
problem. Reagan - January 20, 1981
Ian B MacLure
2009-01-14 03:02:10 UTC
Permalink
Post by i***@stable.bin
What It Was Like Being Forced to Leave Palestine 60 Years Ago
Nice try Accchhhhhhhhmed.
If yer family pulled stakes back in '49 it was because they
expected to be able to return once Arab armies had finished
killing all the Jews.
Hows that workin' out fer ya?

IBM
Paul Simon
2009-01-14 18:07:01 UTC
Permalink
Post by Ian B MacLure
Post by i***@stable.bin
What It Was Like Being Forced to Leave Palestine 60 Years Ago
Nice try Accchhhhhhhhmed.
If yer family pulled stakes back in '49 it was because they
expected to be able to return once Arab armies had finished
killing all the Jews.
Hows that workin' out fer ya?
IBM
You sound like a dead terrorist yourself, Ian. Brain dead at least.
Ian B MacLure
2009-01-15 05:59:59 UTC
Permalink
Post by Paul Simon
Post by Ian B MacLure
Post by i***@stable.bin
What It Was Like Being Forced to Leave Palestine 60 Years Ago
Nice try Accchhhhhhhhmed.
If yer family pulled stakes back in '49 it was because they
expected to be able to return once Arab armies had finished
killing all the Jews.
Hows that workin' out fer ya?
IBM
You sound like a dead terrorist yourself, Ian. Brain dead at least.
Nah thats just your galloping cacaphrenia.

IBM

Lobby Dosser
2009-01-14 07:59:27 UTC
Permalink
Post by i***@stable.bin
What It Was Like Being Forced to Leave Palestine 60 Years Ago
By Suzanne Manneh, New America Media. Posted January 13, 2009.
Palestinian expats tell their stories from decades ago when they were
forced to flee their homeland.
The Grand Mufti FORCED them?! Who Knew!!
Loading...