Paul Simon
2008-12-23 15:19:45 UTC
The 10 Greediest People of 2008
By Sam Pizzigati, Too Much: A Commentary on Excess and Inequality.
Posted December 23, 2008.
For obvious reasons, we probably couldn't have picked a better year
than 2008 to "honor" our most avaricious.
This time of year always seems to bring a never-ending barrage of "top
ten" lists. The year's top ten movies, the top ten books, the top ten
news stories, and on and on. Here at Too Much we've decided to join in
on the action -- with our very own list of America's top ten
greediest.
We probably couldn't have picked a better year than 2008 to so "honor"
our most avaricious. This year's stunning economic meltdown has fixed
the attention of our entire nation -- and world -- on the grasping
antics of those who yearn for ever more than they could rationally
ever need.
But this year also presents enormous challenges for anyone bold enough
to rank the greedy. With so much greed out there, how could we
possibly limit our list to a mere ten?
The latest greed explosion to hit the headlines -- the $50 billion
Bernie Madoff Ponzi scheme -- illustrates just how difficult a task
ranking the greedy can be.
To whom in this scandal should we award the most greed points? Bernie
Madoff himself, the 70-year-old who scammed his wealthy friends and
charities to keep up his credentials as a Wall Street investing
"genius" -- and maintain a $6 million pad in Manhattan, a waterfront
mansion in Palm Beach, and a weekend getaway on Long Island?
Or should those greed points go instead to the ever-so-sophisticated
hedge fund "middlemen" like Walter Noel, who built a five-manse
fortune by steering clients to Madoff and charging them tens of
millions in "due diligence" fees for the steering.
Or should the greed points go to Madoff's investors themselves, the
swells who pay $250,000 a year for the privilege of belonging to a
swanky country club?
So many choices! How about James Cayne, the Bear Stearns CEO who rode
toxic securities into billionairedom? Or Angelo Mozilo, who took the
same ride at Countrywide Financial, spreading suffering to subprimed
families all along the way?
In the end, we came to realize, the size of the fortune alone doesn't
determine greed. It's the thought that counts. In that holiday spirit,
we hope you find our top ten greedy list of some interest -- and
greed-busting inspiration.
10: Dwight Schar
Any list of 2009's greediest has to start, of course, with the
power-suits who pumped up -- and profited ever so lavishly from -- the
now-burst housing bubble. In November, Wall Street Journal researchers
scoured the records of firms that build and finance housing and found
15 top executives who have pocketed, "in cash compensation and
proceeds from stock sales," at least $100 million over the past five
years.
Among the fortunate 15: Dwight Schar, the chair of homebuilding giant
NVR Inc. The 66-year-old Schar has cleared $625 million since 2002. In
2004, he spent a good chunk of that buying an ocean-facing mansion in
Florida's Palm Beach for $70 million, the highest price up to then
ever paid for a U.S. residential property. The seven-bedroom home came
with a walk-in humidor for cigars.
Schar's legal residence, a gated estate just north of Washington,
D.C., sits on 10 acres overlooking the Potomac. NVR stock has dropped
over 60 percent since its housing bubble peak, but neither of Schar's
two main residences figures to foreclose anytime soon.
9: Patrick Soon-Shiong
Why does health care in the United States cost so much? Maybe somebody
should ask Patrick Soon-Shiong, the Los Angeles drug developer who
this September saw his personal fortune -- $3 billion last year --
take a giant first step toward more than doubling.
Soon-Shiong came into 2008 as the chief executive of APP
Pharmaceuticals. He stepped down as CEO in the spring, but the former
surgeon still held 83 percent of the company's shares. In July, he
agreed to sell APP to a German firm. The sale finalized two months
later for an initial $3.7 billion cash payment.
What made APP so attractive? The company is minting money. In 2007,
notes the Los Angeles Business Journal, APP scored $253 million in
adjusted earnings on just $647 million of sales. The firm started this
year off on an equally profitable tear when a contamination scare in
China left APP the only U.S. source of a widely used blood-thinner.
That drug quickly doubled in price.
8: Richard Baker
This hasn't been a great year for the hedge fund industry. The funds
-- largely unregulated investment vehicles open only to deep-pocket
investors -- are suffering their worst year ever, down 19 percent
through November. But the industry has certainly been sweet this year
to at least one lucky fellow, former Congressman Richard Baker from
Louisiana.
Back in February, Baker gave up his House seat -- and his $169,300
House salary -- to become the president and CEO of the Managed Funds
Association, the hedge fund industry's trade association.
What led the 60-year-old Baker, a lawmaker since the age of 23, to
give up his life of public service? Maybe the private gain. As the
hedge fund trade group chief, the New Orleans Times-Picayune reported
earlier this year, Baker would be taking home a $1 million annual
salary and benefits package.
What made Baker so attractive to America's hedge fund billionaires? As
the chair of the House Financial Services Subcommittee on Capital
Markets, the Center for Responsible Politics notes, Baker had been
overseeing the very industry he would, as the hedge fund top gun, be
representing.
7: James Mulva
Back last spring, with motorists turning purple with rage every time
they pulled in for a fill-up, one Big Oil CEO tried to assure
Americans he shared their pain. Declared ConocoPhillips chief exec
Mulva: "High oil prices have not been our friend" -- because, as he
explained later to reporters, higher per-barrel prices for crude have
resource-rich countries demanding more control over their own oil.
On the other hand, the run-up in crude oil prices over recent years
hasn't exactly left Big Oil broken-hearted. The industry's profits,
the Consumer Federation of America noted this fall, have soared over
600 percent since 2002.
Few have enjoyed more rewards for that success than the 62-year-old
Mulva. He reaped a $50.5 million personal payoff in 2007, according to
federal Securities and Exchange Commission figures. He'll be
collecting, when he retires, at least a $2.6 million annual pension.
6: Ralph Roberts
On January 1, 2008, the Comcast cable TV empire put into effect the
ultimate in executive incentive pay plans: a new deal that guaranteed
the company's founder and executive committee chair, Ralph Roberts,
$1.85 million in basic annual salary for five years after he dies,
with the after-death payout going to whoever Roberts names as his
beneficiary.
In 2007, Roberts, now 88, actually pocketed $24.7 million in total
compensation. His son, current Comcast CEO Brian Roberts, collected
$20.8 million.
Some shareholders, in early 2008, took a bit of umbrage to all this
largesse. Some even began demanding Brian's resignation. In February,
under fire, the Roberts clan backed down. They agreed to ax Ralph's
death benefit and drop his annual salary to $1 a year. But Comcast
will continue to pay Ralph's various benefits, including his life
insurance. In 2006, the premiums ran $10.5 million.
Meanwhile, in November, news reports revealed that federal and state
cable TV regulators fear that Comcast, amid the consumer confusion
over the transition to all-digital over-the-air broadcasts, is pushing
low-income cable TV subscribers into more expensive monthly cable
packages.
5: Steve Jobs
In 2008, once again, the most notable executive in America's $1-a-year
CEO club remained Steve Jobs, the chief exec at Apple Computer. Jobs
has been collecting a mere $1 in annual salary ever since 1997. He
has, to be sure, been collecting a few other rewards as well. He
entered 2008 with about 5.5 million shares of Apple stock and a net
worth not too far south of $6 billion.
This past March, to gain some input into any future rewards that might
come their CEO's way, Apple shareholders passed a resolution that
gives them an advisory "Say on Pay" vote on executive compensation.
Joked Jobs in response: "I hope 'Say on Pay' will help me with my $1 a
year salary."
Apple corporate directors aren't waiting for any shareholder help. In
the company's 2008 proxy statement, they noted that they're already
"considering additional compensation arrangements" for Jobs, given the
"critical" importance of his "continued leadership."
Jobs himself told shareholders at this year's Apple annual meeting
that he "feels confident" that any number of the company's top execs
"could take his place." Even so, he's probably eager to see what sort
of "additional compensation" Apple's imaginative board might have in
mind.
In 1999, the board gave Jobs a $90 million Gulfstream V jet -- and
agreed to pay Jobs for the cost of operating it. In 2007, that cost
came to $776,000.
4: Robert Stevens
Peace on earth and good will toward everybody. But not too soon. That
may be the motto this holiday season for Lockheed Martin, the world's
biggest military contractor. Under CEO Robert Stevens, the company's
profit margins have nearly doubled, thanks in no small part to a 72
percent hike in U.S. defense outlays, after inflation, since the year
2000.
And the future looks equally bright, even with the war in Iraq winding
down. Lockheed Martin, the 57-year-old Stevens noted last month, sees
nothing but "continuous expansion" in its military hardware sales
overseas. These sales can deliver sky-high returns, industry analysts
point out, because U.S. taxpayers have already footed the bill for the
hardware's R&D.
Still, Stevens isn't putting all his eggs in one basket. Lockheed
Martin, he said last week, remains totally "unconstrained" by the
credit crisis and is now investigating making corporate acquisitions
in other fields -- like health care.
The CEO's personal financial health remains quite robust. Stevens
pulled in $26 million last year. The most highly decorated general in
the U.S. armed services would have to work over 130 years to make that
much.
3: Larry Ellison
No state may be suffering from the bursting of the housing bubble more
than California -- and no Californian may be benefiting from that
bursting more than billionaire Larry Ellison, the Oracle business
software chief exec who currently occupies the three-spot on the
latest Forbes list of America's 400 richest.
Ellison spent nine years and $200 million building a lavish Northern
California residential estate -- in the flamboyant style of a 16th
century Japanese emperor. In 2005, San Mateo County officials assessed
the 23-acre property at $166.3 million. Ellison balked. A more
accurate appraisal, his lawyers claimed, would run about $100 million
less.
Early this spring, the San Mateo assessment appeals board came down on
the side of Ellison's lawyers. That decision handed Ellison a $3
million tax refund.
Local public schools are now bearing about half the burden that refund
has generated. In future years, Ellison's tax discount will cost
Portola Valley schools an annual $250,000 or so, the cost of hiring
and supplying three teachers.
Ellison, as Oracle's top executive, takes home about that much every
hour. This August, just before school started, Oracle pay filings
revealed that Ellison collected $84.6 million in fiscal 2008 for his
CEO labors. He also cleared another $544 million cashing in on a stash
of his Oracle stock options.
2: John Thain
In high-finance circles, they called John Thain "Mr. Fix-It." In 2004,
the New York Stock Exchange hired Thain, a rising star at Goldman
Sachs, to clean up the mess after NYSE CEO Dick Grasso departed with a
scandalous $140 million retirement package. Then, in October 2007,
Merrill Lynch asked Thain to pick up the pieces after Merrill's board
gave the heave-ho to CEO Stanley O'Neal, who left with $160 million.
Merrill paid fairly dearly to gain Thain's services. Mr. Fix-It came
on board with a $15 million signing bonus and a bundle of lush
incentives that "would be considered excessive for any industry
anywhere," observed CEO pay expert Graef Crystal, "except on that tiny
slice of Manhattan called Wall Street."
With subprime-spooked financial giants starting to melt down all
around him, Thain went to work wheeling and dealing -- and assuring
bystanders that all would be well. In July, he told investors he "felt
comfortable with Merrill's capital levels." In August, Thain labeled
his firm "well-positioned for the coming years."
Well, maybe not that well-positioned. In September, as Reuters later
reported, Merrill would come within moments of "total extinction" --
only to be rescued, an hour before Lehman Brothers declared
bankruptcy, when Bank of America agreed to swallow Merrill whole.
Merrill Lynch, Thain apparently believed, had been fixed, and, early
this December, he let it be known that he expected up to $10 million
in new bonus for his efforts -- despite Merrill's $12 billion in 2008
losses and a pending layoff of as much as a fifth of the firm's
workforce. On top of all that, Merrill's new sugardaddy, Bank of
America, was taking $25 billion in taxpayer bailout dollars.
Thain's bonus request quickly became a public relations disaster. By
mid-December, Merrill and Thain, under increasing pressure, would
unrequest the bonus millions. The good news for Mr. Fix-It? He still
may get a $5.2 million "change-of-control payment" for selling Merrill
-- and he still has a job.
Unlike average families who lost everything when Merrill's subprime
mortgage securities went sour, Thain still has a house, too. A nice
one, a 14-bedroom palace north of Manhattan complete with tennis
courts, swimming pools, and a fish-filled private lake.
1: Richard Gilman
The CEO of a small factory on Chicago's North Side, by Fortune 500
standards, rates as distinctly small-time. But this particular CEO,
Richard Gilman, helped make headlines -- and history -- in 2008. He
fully deserves this year's premier place in America's top ten
greediest.
Gilman started running Republic Windows and Doors, a modest,
four-decade-old plant, in 2006. Layoffs soon followed, and,
eventually, only about 240 workers remained from a unionized labor
force once over 500 strong.
Those workers, earlier this fall, realized something even more ominous
was coming at them. Equipment at the Chicago plant had started
vanishing. What the workers didn't know: Republic's "deciders" had set
up a new company and bought a nonunion window and door plant in Iowa.
Two days into December, Republic gave workers the bad news. The plant
would shut down three days later. The workers would lose their earned
vacation time and their health insurance -- and not see any of the
severance legally due them.
Just another typical assault on workers with a precarious foothold in
the middle class. Or so things seemed. But the workers then did
something extraordinary. Reviving memories of the Great Depression-era
"sit-down" strikes, they occupied the plant -- and captured America's
imagination.
The sit-down forced Gilman and his money pot, the Bank of America, to
the bargaining table where a settlement soon took shape. But Gilman
suddenly threw a monkey-wrench into the works -- and gained a slot for
himself in this year's top ten greediest.
Gilman demanded that "any new bank loan to help the employees also
cover" the lease of his Mercedes and BMW and eight weeks of his
$225,000 salary.
The workers would have none of that. Gilman would drop his demand. The
bank funding would come through. The workers had won. Greed had lost.
That hasn't much over the last three decades. Maybe the greedy have
finally gone too far. We may have reached the end of an era. America's
generation-long Great Greed Grab may soon be no more.
By Sam Pizzigati, Too Much: A Commentary on Excess and Inequality.
Posted December 23, 2008.
For obvious reasons, we probably couldn't have picked a better year
than 2008 to "honor" our most avaricious.
This time of year always seems to bring a never-ending barrage of "top
ten" lists. The year's top ten movies, the top ten books, the top ten
news stories, and on and on. Here at Too Much we've decided to join in
on the action -- with our very own list of America's top ten
greediest.
We probably couldn't have picked a better year than 2008 to so "honor"
our most avaricious. This year's stunning economic meltdown has fixed
the attention of our entire nation -- and world -- on the grasping
antics of those who yearn for ever more than they could rationally
ever need.
But this year also presents enormous challenges for anyone bold enough
to rank the greedy. With so much greed out there, how could we
possibly limit our list to a mere ten?
The latest greed explosion to hit the headlines -- the $50 billion
Bernie Madoff Ponzi scheme -- illustrates just how difficult a task
ranking the greedy can be.
To whom in this scandal should we award the most greed points? Bernie
Madoff himself, the 70-year-old who scammed his wealthy friends and
charities to keep up his credentials as a Wall Street investing
"genius" -- and maintain a $6 million pad in Manhattan, a waterfront
mansion in Palm Beach, and a weekend getaway on Long Island?
Or should those greed points go instead to the ever-so-sophisticated
hedge fund "middlemen" like Walter Noel, who built a five-manse
fortune by steering clients to Madoff and charging them tens of
millions in "due diligence" fees for the steering.
Or should the greed points go to Madoff's investors themselves, the
swells who pay $250,000 a year for the privilege of belonging to a
swanky country club?
So many choices! How about James Cayne, the Bear Stearns CEO who rode
toxic securities into billionairedom? Or Angelo Mozilo, who took the
same ride at Countrywide Financial, spreading suffering to subprimed
families all along the way?
In the end, we came to realize, the size of the fortune alone doesn't
determine greed. It's the thought that counts. In that holiday spirit,
we hope you find our top ten greedy list of some interest -- and
greed-busting inspiration.
10: Dwight Schar
Any list of 2009's greediest has to start, of course, with the
power-suits who pumped up -- and profited ever so lavishly from -- the
now-burst housing bubble. In November, Wall Street Journal researchers
scoured the records of firms that build and finance housing and found
15 top executives who have pocketed, "in cash compensation and
proceeds from stock sales," at least $100 million over the past five
years.
Among the fortunate 15: Dwight Schar, the chair of homebuilding giant
NVR Inc. The 66-year-old Schar has cleared $625 million since 2002. In
2004, he spent a good chunk of that buying an ocean-facing mansion in
Florida's Palm Beach for $70 million, the highest price up to then
ever paid for a U.S. residential property. The seven-bedroom home came
with a walk-in humidor for cigars.
Schar's legal residence, a gated estate just north of Washington,
D.C., sits on 10 acres overlooking the Potomac. NVR stock has dropped
over 60 percent since its housing bubble peak, but neither of Schar's
two main residences figures to foreclose anytime soon.
9: Patrick Soon-Shiong
Why does health care in the United States cost so much? Maybe somebody
should ask Patrick Soon-Shiong, the Los Angeles drug developer who
this September saw his personal fortune -- $3 billion last year --
take a giant first step toward more than doubling.
Soon-Shiong came into 2008 as the chief executive of APP
Pharmaceuticals. He stepped down as CEO in the spring, but the former
surgeon still held 83 percent of the company's shares. In July, he
agreed to sell APP to a German firm. The sale finalized two months
later for an initial $3.7 billion cash payment.
What made APP so attractive? The company is minting money. In 2007,
notes the Los Angeles Business Journal, APP scored $253 million in
adjusted earnings on just $647 million of sales. The firm started this
year off on an equally profitable tear when a contamination scare in
China left APP the only U.S. source of a widely used blood-thinner.
That drug quickly doubled in price.
8: Richard Baker
This hasn't been a great year for the hedge fund industry. The funds
-- largely unregulated investment vehicles open only to deep-pocket
investors -- are suffering their worst year ever, down 19 percent
through November. But the industry has certainly been sweet this year
to at least one lucky fellow, former Congressman Richard Baker from
Louisiana.
Back in February, Baker gave up his House seat -- and his $169,300
House salary -- to become the president and CEO of the Managed Funds
Association, the hedge fund industry's trade association.
What led the 60-year-old Baker, a lawmaker since the age of 23, to
give up his life of public service? Maybe the private gain. As the
hedge fund trade group chief, the New Orleans Times-Picayune reported
earlier this year, Baker would be taking home a $1 million annual
salary and benefits package.
What made Baker so attractive to America's hedge fund billionaires? As
the chair of the House Financial Services Subcommittee on Capital
Markets, the Center for Responsible Politics notes, Baker had been
overseeing the very industry he would, as the hedge fund top gun, be
representing.
7: James Mulva
Back last spring, with motorists turning purple with rage every time
they pulled in for a fill-up, one Big Oil CEO tried to assure
Americans he shared their pain. Declared ConocoPhillips chief exec
Mulva: "High oil prices have not been our friend" -- because, as he
explained later to reporters, higher per-barrel prices for crude have
resource-rich countries demanding more control over their own oil.
On the other hand, the run-up in crude oil prices over recent years
hasn't exactly left Big Oil broken-hearted. The industry's profits,
the Consumer Federation of America noted this fall, have soared over
600 percent since 2002.
Few have enjoyed more rewards for that success than the 62-year-old
Mulva. He reaped a $50.5 million personal payoff in 2007, according to
federal Securities and Exchange Commission figures. He'll be
collecting, when he retires, at least a $2.6 million annual pension.
6: Ralph Roberts
On January 1, 2008, the Comcast cable TV empire put into effect the
ultimate in executive incentive pay plans: a new deal that guaranteed
the company's founder and executive committee chair, Ralph Roberts,
$1.85 million in basic annual salary for five years after he dies,
with the after-death payout going to whoever Roberts names as his
beneficiary.
In 2007, Roberts, now 88, actually pocketed $24.7 million in total
compensation. His son, current Comcast CEO Brian Roberts, collected
$20.8 million.
Some shareholders, in early 2008, took a bit of umbrage to all this
largesse. Some even began demanding Brian's resignation. In February,
under fire, the Roberts clan backed down. They agreed to ax Ralph's
death benefit and drop his annual salary to $1 a year. But Comcast
will continue to pay Ralph's various benefits, including his life
insurance. In 2006, the premiums ran $10.5 million.
Meanwhile, in November, news reports revealed that federal and state
cable TV regulators fear that Comcast, amid the consumer confusion
over the transition to all-digital over-the-air broadcasts, is pushing
low-income cable TV subscribers into more expensive monthly cable
packages.
5: Steve Jobs
In 2008, once again, the most notable executive in America's $1-a-year
CEO club remained Steve Jobs, the chief exec at Apple Computer. Jobs
has been collecting a mere $1 in annual salary ever since 1997. He
has, to be sure, been collecting a few other rewards as well. He
entered 2008 with about 5.5 million shares of Apple stock and a net
worth not too far south of $6 billion.
This past March, to gain some input into any future rewards that might
come their CEO's way, Apple shareholders passed a resolution that
gives them an advisory "Say on Pay" vote on executive compensation.
Joked Jobs in response: "I hope 'Say on Pay' will help me with my $1 a
year salary."
Apple corporate directors aren't waiting for any shareholder help. In
the company's 2008 proxy statement, they noted that they're already
"considering additional compensation arrangements" for Jobs, given the
"critical" importance of his "continued leadership."
Jobs himself told shareholders at this year's Apple annual meeting
that he "feels confident" that any number of the company's top execs
"could take his place." Even so, he's probably eager to see what sort
of "additional compensation" Apple's imaginative board might have in
mind.
In 1999, the board gave Jobs a $90 million Gulfstream V jet -- and
agreed to pay Jobs for the cost of operating it. In 2007, that cost
came to $776,000.
4: Robert Stevens
Peace on earth and good will toward everybody. But not too soon. That
may be the motto this holiday season for Lockheed Martin, the world's
biggest military contractor. Under CEO Robert Stevens, the company's
profit margins have nearly doubled, thanks in no small part to a 72
percent hike in U.S. defense outlays, after inflation, since the year
2000.
And the future looks equally bright, even with the war in Iraq winding
down. Lockheed Martin, the 57-year-old Stevens noted last month, sees
nothing but "continuous expansion" in its military hardware sales
overseas. These sales can deliver sky-high returns, industry analysts
point out, because U.S. taxpayers have already footed the bill for the
hardware's R&D.
Still, Stevens isn't putting all his eggs in one basket. Lockheed
Martin, he said last week, remains totally "unconstrained" by the
credit crisis and is now investigating making corporate acquisitions
in other fields -- like health care.
The CEO's personal financial health remains quite robust. Stevens
pulled in $26 million last year. The most highly decorated general in
the U.S. armed services would have to work over 130 years to make that
much.
3: Larry Ellison
No state may be suffering from the bursting of the housing bubble more
than California -- and no Californian may be benefiting from that
bursting more than billionaire Larry Ellison, the Oracle business
software chief exec who currently occupies the three-spot on the
latest Forbes list of America's 400 richest.
Ellison spent nine years and $200 million building a lavish Northern
California residential estate -- in the flamboyant style of a 16th
century Japanese emperor. In 2005, San Mateo County officials assessed
the 23-acre property at $166.3 million. Ellison balked. A more
accurate appraisal, his lawyers claimed, would run about $100 million
less.
Early this spring, the San Mateo assessment appeals board came down on
the side of Ellison's lawyers. That decision handed Ellison a $3
million tax refund.
Local public schools are now bearing about half the burden that refund
has generated. In future years, Ellison's tax discount will cost
Portola Valley schools an annual $250,000 or so, the cost of hiring
and supplying three teachers.
Ellison, as Oracle's top executive, takes home about that much every
hour. This August, just before school started, Oracle pay filings
revealed that Ellison collected $84.6 million in fiscal 2008 for his
CEO labors. He also cleared another $544 million cashing in on a stash
of his Oracle stock options.
2: John Thain
In high-finance circles, they called John Thain "Mr. Fix-It." In 2004,
the New York Stock Exchange hired Thain, a rising star at Goldman
Sachs, to clean up the mess after NYSE CEO Dick Grasso departed with a
scandalous $140 million retirement package. Then, in October 2007,
Merrill Lynch asked Thain to pick up the pieces after Merrill's board
gave the heave-ho to CEO Stanley O'Neal, who left with $160 million.
Merrill paid fairly dearly to gain Thain's services. Mr. Fix-It came
on board with a $15 million signing bonus and a bundle of lush
incentives that "would be considered excessive for any industry
anywhere," observed CEO pay expert Graef Crystal, "except on that tiny
slice of Manhattan called Wall Street."
With subprime-spooked financial giants starting to melt down all
around him, Thain went to work wheeling and dealing -- and assuring
bystanders that all would be well. In July, he told investors he "felt
comfortable with Merrill's capital levels." In August, Thain labeled
his firm "well-positioned for the coming years."
Well, maybe not that well-positioned. In September, as Reuters later
reported, Merrill would come within moments of "total extinction" --
only to be rescued, an hour before Lehman Brothers declared
bankruptcy, when Bank of America agreed to swallow Merrill whole.
Merrill Lynch, Thain apparently believed, had been fixed, and, early
this December, he let it be known that he expected up to $10 million
in new bonus for his efforts -- despite Merrill's $12 billion in 2008
losses and a pending layoff of as much as a fifth of the firm's
workforce. On top of all that, Merrill's new sugardaddy, Bank of
America, was taking $25 billion in taxpayer bailout dollars.
Thain's bonus request quickly became a public relations disaster. By
mid-December, Merrill and Thain, under increasing pressure, would
unrequest the bonus millions. The good news for Mr. Fix-It? He still
may get a $5.2 million "change-of-control payment" for selling Merrill
-- and he still has a job.
Unlike average families who lost everything when Merrill's subprime
mortgage securities went sour, Thain still has a house, too. A nice
one, a 14-bedroom palace north of Manhattan complete with tennis
courts, swimming pools, and a fish-filled private lake.
1: Richard Gilman
The CEO of a small factory on Chicago's North Side, by Fortune 500
standards, rates as distinctly small-time. But this particular CEO,
Richard Gilman, helped make headlines -- and history -- in 2008. He
fully deserves this year's premier place in America's top ten
greediest.
Gilman started running Republic Windows and Doors, a modest,
four-decade-old plant, in 2006. Layoffs soon followed, and,
eventually, only about 240 workers remained from a unionized labor
force once over 500 strong.
Those workers, earlier this fall, realized something even more ominous
was coming at them. Equipment at the Chicago plant had started
vanishing. What the workers didn't know: Republic's "deciders" had set
up a new company and bought a nonunion window and door plant in Iowa.
Two days into December, Republic gave workers the bad news. The plant
would shut down three days later. The workers would lose their earned
vacation time and their health insurance -- and not see any of the
severance legally due them.
Just another typical assault on workers with a precarious foothold in
the middle class. Or so things seemed. But the workers then did
something extraordinary. Reviving memories of the Great Depression-era
"sit-down" strikes, they occupied the plant -- and captured America's
imagination.
The sit-down forced Gilman and his money pot, the Bank of America, to
the bargaining table where a settlement soon took shape. But Gilman
suddenly threw a monkey-wrench into the works -- and gained a slot for
himself in this year's top ten greediest.
Gilman demanded that "any new bank loan to help the employees also
cover" the lease of his Mercedes and BMW and eight weeks of his
$225,000 salary.
The workers would have none of that. Gilman would drop his demand. The
bank funding would come through. The workers had won. Greed had lost.
That hasn't much over the last three decades. Maybe the greedy have
finally gone too far. We may have reached the end of an era. America's
generation-long Great Greed Grab may soon be no more.